Join Our Mailing List!

URJ Press

Transcontinental Music Publications

Sounds Write Music

Request a Catalog

Upcoming Events

F.A.Q.s

Photo Album

Discussion Guides

Biographies for
Authors/Composers:

Subscription Programs:

Visit other Reform
publication web sites:

Discussion Guides

The Tenth of Av Activity Guide for
the Kenneth Roseman
Do-It-Yourself Adventure Series
The Tenth of Av

Activity Guide by
Deborah Niederman

The Tenth of Av

Background

In 63 B.C.E. Judea became a vassal state of Rome, but the Jews were allowed to have a Jewish king. The kingship was actually bought from the corrupt Roman officials, who would attempt to make as much money as possible from their regions through bribery or legal means and then keep as much as they could. Even with a Jewish ruler, the hardship that the Jews felt under Roman rule was extremely difficult. The Jews revolted against Roman rule in 70 C.E. and the Second Temple was destroyed later that same year. One response to the destruction of the Second Temple and the continuing Roman rule was embodied in the actions of Rabbi Yohanan Ben Zakkai. Fearing that all of Judaism would end, Ben Zakkai escaped Jerusalem with his disciples and founded an academy of learning in Yavneh. He also moved the Sanhedrin, the governing body of rabbis, to this town on the Mediterranean. Ben Zakkai helped Judaism adapt to a new way of life outside of Jerusalem. Another response to the destruction of the Temple can be seen in the actions of the Zealots who refused to surrender to Roman rule. After the Temple's destruction, they fled to the mountain fortress of Masada. After a prolonged siege, in 73 C.E. the Jews of Masada committed suicide rather than be taken prisoner.

Along with Roman rule, the Jews faced another difficult issue after the fall of Jerusalem. With the Temple gone, sacrifice, the primary means of communicating with God, came to an end. But the Jews had been through this before, with the destruction of the First Temple and the first exile to Babylon. During this first dispersion they established synagogues in Babylonia and developed a system of religious practice based on the mitzvot of the Torah. (The word "synagogue" is actually a Greek translation of beit k'nesset -- translated from Hebrew as a house of gathering -- and means "place of assembly.")

When Jews returned from this exile and the Second Temple was built, these new practices did not disappear. The idea of a local synagogue was appealing to people who lived outside of Jerusalem and who would likely only visit the Second Temple during the three pilgrimage festivals (Sukkot, Pesach and Shavuot) if at all.

With the Greek conquest in 332 B.C.E., an emphasis on literacy followed; by the end of the second century B.C.E., literacy was widespread throughout Judea. There had been public reading of the Torah since the time of Ezra in the fifth century B.C.E. Archaeology, especially with the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls, confirms the existence of written scrolls of Torah, history and law as early as the third century B.C.E. At this time two components existed in Jewish law. The written law, meaning that given on Sinai (the five books of the Torah) and the oral law, the interpretations of the generations that followed. These traditions were maintained in oral form until the second century B.C.E. when the oral law was compiled and written down in a document called the Mishnah. Later the Mishnah would become one half of the Talmud. Over the next few centuries, commentaries elaborating on the Mishnah were written down in Jerusalem and Babylon. These additional commentaries are known as the Gemara. The Gemara and the Mishnah together are known as the Talmud, which was completed in the fifth century B.C.E. There are actually two Talmuds: the Jerusalem Talmud and the Babylonian Talmud. The Babylonian Talmud is more comprehensive, and is more frequently consulted and studied.

Classroom activities for The Tenth of Av

  1. Examine a page of Talmud. Focusing on the Mishnah, study the page layout. Show students how the other texts interact with the Mishnah text. How would they arrange their page of important thoughts if it were intended to be surrounded by commentary? Have the students create a page of Talmud using one important Jewish law from the Mishnah.
  2. Have the rabbi come in and lead the students in a study of Mishnah.
  3. One of the archaeological discoveries that has taught us the most about this period in history is the Dead Sea Scrolls. To do research on the Dead Sea Scrolls, use these resources: "The Dead Sea Scrolls Revealed," cd-rom (Pivel Multimedia Ltd & Aaron Witkin Associates) or view the video "The Dead Sea in Biblical Times" (Ergo Media).
  4. The Dead Sea Scrolls were like a time capsule when the archaeologists found them. Ask the students to make a Jewish time capsule for today. Challenge them to think carefully about what they would put inside.
  5. Invite students to write the names of the people they choose to follow as they do their adventure. Help each group research the historical figure that they think played the most important role in the events that occurred after the destruction of Jerusalem, and then do a report on that person.
  6. View and discuss maps of Jerusalem right before the destruction of the Second Temple. Explain the different parts of Jerusalem at that time and how the influence of Rome could be seen in the buildings and architecture of the city. Finally, compare Jerusalem before 70 C.E. to the Jerusalem of today. Maps of Jerusalem can be found in Carta's Historical Atlas of Jerusalem (Carta).
  7. Discuss the saying from Rabbinic literature that the Second Temple was destroyed because of baseless hatred between Jews. What does conflict between Jews have to do with the Roman's conquering Jerusalem? The Rabbinic saying can be found in The Book of Legends (Schocken, 1992), page 193.
  8. Re-tell the Rabbinic legend of Yohanan Ben Zakkai escaping Jerusalem before its destruction. Ben Zakkai managed to convince the Roman general Vespesian to allow him and his disciples to leave Jerusalem and found a house of study in Yavneh. Discuss the wisdom of Ben Zakkai's decision to maintain Judaism despite the imminent destruction of the Temple and Jerusalem. One version of the story can be found in The Book of Legends, pages 190-191.
  9. To introduce students to the further development of text and Jewish law, explore the texts of Responsa. There are great resources on the CCAR home page at http://ccarnet.org/ (look under Responsa) or go to http://ccarnet.org/resp/. Choose a question that would be of interest to the students and have them create answers. Then show the actual response.
  10. Other resources for additional study include Sefer Ha-Aggadah: The Book of Legends for Young People Vol. 1 and 2 (UAHC Press, 1996 and 1998); Meet Our Sages and Learn Mishna (Behrman House, 1978).
  11. View and discuss the movie "Masada" (Ergo Media).

 

 


ABOUT URJ BOOKS & MUSIC

633 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017   |   P 212.650.4120   |   F 212.650.4119
www.urjbooksandmusic.com   |   press@urj.org

HOME          CONTACT US          SEARCH FOR ITEMS          VIEW CART